Altair
Skip to content

Trading Analysis Report: HL

Analysis date: 2026-10-03 · Model: claude-opus-5-5 · AI-generated, not financial advice.

  • Analysis date: 2026-10-03
  • Rating: Underweight
  • Generated: 2026-10-04 14:05:35

V. Portfolio Manager Decision

Rating: Underweight

Executive Summary: Underweight HL at the $17.20 close. A full-weight holder sells to about one-third of a standard allocation on Mon-Tue 10/5-10/6 near $17.20, works the rest on limits at $17.63-17.74 (market-on-close on any close below $16.90), and must be down to the residual by the Fri 10/9 close, or the close before CPI if that comes first; flat or lighter accounts do not buy up to these levels, and nobody adds before CPI. Size the residual so a two-ATR gap measured from the stop costs no more than 2.5% of a full position: up to 20% of a standard allocation with a live option chain, about 17% without one, 10% if the 10-year closes above its late-September high or HL closes below $16.90, and zero if silver closes below its main uptrend. Exit the residual on a daily close below $16.70 (the rating then becomes Sell) or at the resting $16.10 stop, rebuild only after CPI on qualifying closes above $17.74 (at least 36.7M shares, OBV above 1,020.6M, a rising MACD histogram, benign yields and silver), and cap the position at half weight until early-November Q3 results pass; the horizon is 5-6 weeks with a $15.47 downside objective, and full weight plus a Hold rating require a Q3 pass and a close above the higher of $18.25 and the 50-day with OBV above 1,111M and a positive MACD histogram.

Current Price: 17.2

Price Target: 15.47

Confidence: Medium

Time Horizon: 5-6 weeks

9. Risks and watch items

  1. Metal-price sensitivity: with 83–86% of extra revenue reaching profit, earnings swing sharply with silver and gold prices. The 2013–15, 2018–19 and 2022–23 downturns all produced losses and negative FCF.
  2. Slowing quarters:
  3. Gross profit fell 29% from Q1 to Q2 2026.
  4. Q3 2026 results (likely early November, date unconfirmed) should show the cause. If gross profit holds near $180M or more, the drop was mainly from the asset sale. If it keeps falling, prices or operations are to blame.
  5. Concentration: after the sale, results depend more heavily on Greens Creek, Lucky Friday and Keno Hill.
  6. Higher H2 capex and cash taxes could both reduce FCF.
  7. Capital allocation: $483M of cash plus about $135M of quarterly FCF allows buybacks, dividends or further debt repayment. It also allows acquisitions, and all three past deals were followed by years of losses.
  8. Data gaps: no valuation data, no insider data, no quarterly revenue, and details of the Q1 2026 sale are unconfirmed.